To view above photo in Flickr, go to http://www.flickr.com/photos/yummies4tummies/2879988063/in/set-72157607440509123
This recipe was my contribution for a potluck party yesterday. I hadn’t baked in a month, and had my heart set on making this after my hiatus, LOL. I bought all the ingredients last Wednesday. Maybe going to 3 stores to find a Heath bar should have been my clue that I was gonna be put through the wringer. I made this Saturday night and it was a near-disaster. First off, opening 32 caramel wrappers is NOT my idea of fun. 10, 16 maybe, but 32? It got tedious after 20.
The first step is heating up the butter, caramels and condensed milk until it’s all smooth. Easy enough, right? Wrong! I thought I was paying attention (because I hate do-overs). About a fifth of the caramels got scorched. Scorched as in black. Grrrrr! How does something in liquid even burn like that? I transferred the globs of caramels to a plate and used a fork to scrape off the burnt areas. Caramel is a sticky substance, so trying to peel off a part of its structure is no pleasant feat.
I took all the remaining caramels in the bag (about a dozen or so) and started unwrapping ’em. Fun fun fun. This time I heated the pan for about a minute, then stirred until it was all smooth. The rest of the process went off without a hitch, thank goodness, until………….
It took foreeeeeeeeever to bake. I did the toothpick test over and over again every 5 minutes after what the recipe calls for, and it still wasn’t ready. By the time it was done, I was sooo through. I didn’t even want to look at it (which is so unlike me). About an hour and a half later, I did cut a small piece to try it (I had already figured I was going to have to bake something else before the night was over). It was hard, nowhere close to chewy; not a good sign. I was spent. After all that, I resigned to buying a dessert.
The next morning, I tried a small piece again. Guess what? It was soft. WTH?
I could taste how rich it was–thanks to the caramel–and cut ’em into small (2-inch) squares.
The verdict was a few people asked what it was and said it was good. Redemption! It won’t be in the near future, but this will definitely be a do-over. If you’re like me, I need to feel the warm fuzzies about a recipe before I add it to my personal collection.
Yield: 2 dozen